Skip to Content

Easy Thrifted Lamp Makeover

Here is an Easy Thrifted Lamp Makeover using a Goodwill $7.00 lamp to create a Pottery Barn knock-off earthenware look. This update was achieved for a fraction of the cost of a new lamp.

Y’all, I’ve been obsessing over these earthenware lamps I’ve been seeing at Pottery Barn and Anthropologie. I shared some of them with you earlier this week on 17 Farmhouse Decor Trends. So do you know what I did? I searched for a similarly shaped lamp while thrifting, and here’s what happened.

First, The Lamp

It would be best to have an idea of what you want before thrifting. So, I studied and took screenshots of the lamps I liked.

Sometimes, I think, “this was meant to be”! I walked right into my local Goodwill and immediately spotted this lamp.

Lamp from thrift store.

I was thrilled with the size and shape of this $7.00 lamp.

(Posts on The Ponds Farmhouse may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. See the full disclosure details here.)

Thrifted Lamp Makeover

The first step is to add some texture. One of the easiest ways to do this is to use Rust-oleum Textured Spray Paint to cover the entire surface.

Add textured paint to the lamp base.

Gather Supplies

Next, gather all your supplies.

I was planning as I went but here are the things I used.

Supplies for lamp transformation

Add More Texture

Paint the lamp base with old white chalk paint

Using a chip brush, add a thin layer of Plaster of Paris over the entire surface and let it dry.

Next, using the plastic spatula apply a coat of thicker plaster over the entire surface.

add plaster of paris the the thrifted lamp base

You can see another method to achieve an earthenware look when I shared this DIY Faux Earthenware Vessel.

Then, once the plaster is set, you can use light-grit sandpaper to smooth any rough edges.

It’s best to do this while the plaster is still drying because it’s easier to work with, and you avoid all the dust. I sanded after the plaster had set for approx. 20 minutes.

Sand the plaster of paris on the lamp

Add Color to your Thrifted Lamp

The next step will depend on what exact finish you like. As I worked on this project, I had two different inspiration lamps in mind: one from Pottery Barn with all the texture and the other from Anthropologie with the colors. So, I did a mix of both.

Click the shop name above to see these inspiration lamps.

I chose three colors for my lamp. First, the base is Graphite Chalk Paint, and the bottom is French Linen.

Paint thrift store lamp

Then, using the Old White Chalk paint, I painted the top and allowed it to bleed down over the French Linen paint.

Seal with Wax

Finally, you will want to seal the surface of your lamp. I used a mixture of Clear and Dark Wax because I wanted to allow some of the dark wax to settle into the trowel marks and add depth to the texture of the Plaster of Paris finish.

If you don’t want to darken your lamp, you should use the clear wax alone or use a spray sealant such as Rust-0lenum Clear Sealer in a satin finish.

Add clear and dark wax to lamp makeover

Thrifted Lamp Makeover Final Reveal

How do you like it? I love the texture and the colors. Still not sure about the lampshade, but I have my receipt. LOL

Thrift Store Lamp Pottery Barn Dupe
DIY Thrift Store Lamp Transformation After

Did you see this chest before, during, and after the transformation? If not, click here to check it out.

Thrift store lamp makeover after!  Lamp on books in bedroom

More thrift store finds and transformations can be found Here – Apothecary Cabinet & Here – Industrial Transformation.

Just as a reminder, here is the before – the inspiration – and the after.

In an update, the lamp received a new shade, which adds to this bedroom tour’s vintage charm.

You will love the other repurposed lighting posts if you enjoyed this post.

More Favorite DIY Projects

Thanks so much for stopping by today!

Pin It To Remember It

Did you find some great ideas you’d like to save for future reference? To save, hover over the images and pin to your favorite Pinterest Boards when you see the PIN button in the upper left-hand corner.

Pottery Barn Dupe - Easy Lamp Makeover Tutorial
Easy Thrifted lamp makeover

Easy Thrifted lamp makeover pottery barn hack

Lina Jamison

Thursday 10th of August 2023

Thank you so much for the easy to see instructions with great photos! You have really inspired me to get started on my fall decor! Happy gathering! Lina


Friday 11th of August 2023

Lina, Thank you so much. I'm so glad you found this helpful. Thanks for stopping by.

Cheryl Atkinson

Friday 17th of February 2023

Rachel!!! That lamp came out spot on to your inspiration!! It looks amazing. That was the perfect lamp to redo. Pinned


Friday 17th of February 2023

Cheryl, I really appreciate your comments. Thanks for stopping by.

Leisa Haynes

Wednesday 15th of February 2023

That lamp looks great! Thanks for showing how to make it...I'm going to look for it.


Thursday 16th of February 2023

Leisa, I'm so glad you like it.

Margie Clements

Tuesday 14th of February 2023

Happy Valentine's Day to you! And I totally understand and it's was fine! Hope your day is filled with lots of love ❤️


Thursday 16th of February 2023

Margie, I appreciate this so much.

Gail Fickle

Monday 13th of February 2023

Love your lamp and I like the shade. I’ve never used chalk paint but got a project I’m working on and want to use it, any suggestions on using it


Thursday 16th of February 2023

Gail, It's so easy to use. Hard to make a mistake.