Skip to Content

6 Mouthwatering Thanksgiving Pie Recipes To Try For 2023

Who wants pie for Thanksgiving dessert? How would you like to have some guaranteed mouthwatering Thanksgiving Pie Recipes to try this year? As family and friends gather, there’s nothing better than freshly baked pie. If you are looking for some easy pie recipes that are a new take on traditional Thanksgiving desserts, look no further than these 6 amazing recipes that will wow your guests.

You know that Thanksgiving is a time of feasting on Turkey and Ham. However, if you have a sweet tooth like me, the Thanksgiving Desserts steal the show.

Thanksgiving recipes center around harvest time and many desserts are made with fruits and vegetables harvested in the fall.

Here are some of the most popular Thanksgiving Desserts; you’ll notice that many are pies.

  • Pumpkin Pie is one of the first recipes people think of when referring to Thanksgiving Desserts.
  • Apple Pie
  • Sweet Potato Pie
  • Pecan Pie
  • Cranberry Pie
  • Carrot Cake
  • German Chocolate Cake

Supper Club Thanksgiving Pie Party Recipes

Today, pie recipes are part of our monthly Supper Club series. We shared how to host and set up a Thanksgiving Pie Party this month. Each hostess shared a creative table setting and a delicious pie recipe.

This month, Diane from South House Designs joined us as a guest host, and I know you loved her table setting and will love her pie recipe as well.

If you missed our table ideas, you can still see all the tips at Budget Tips to Set Up a Thanksgiving Pie Party Buffet.

Table set up for a Thanksgiving Pie 
Party with rustic farmhouse style decor, earthenware pottery and DIY tableware.

6 Mouthwatering Thanksgiving Pie Recipes

Today, I’m sharing all the recipes used for our Supper Club Thanksgiving Pie Party. There is a good variety of recipes, and I’m sure one or more will grace your Thanksgiving table this year.

Let’s take a look at these delicious Thanksgiving pie recipes.

The Easiest Cranberry Dump Pie

Cranberry Dump Pie Recipe for Thanksgiving Desserts that will impress your guests served on leaf plates.

The perfect combination of Sweet and Tangy!

This may be the easiest “it’s so easy even I’ll make it” recipe ever. Plus, it may be the most delicious.

With only eight ingredients, it is an inexpensive Thanksgiving Pie Recipe and perfect for the Christmas holidays as well.

READ Recipe

The Best Pumpkin Pie

By Stacy at Bricks N Blooms

Pumpkin Pie recipe with flaky crust and whipped topping for a delicious Thanksgiving Pie Recipe.

If you are looking for a simple, easy-to-follow, traditional Pumpkin Pie recipe, look no further than Stacy’s yummy Pumpkin Pie.

Made with a flaky pie crust and a creamy, spiced filling, this pie will surely be a hit with everyone at the table.

READ Recipe

Easy Buttermilk Pumpkin Pie Recipe

By Michele at Vintage Home Designs

Buttermilk Pumpkin Pie Recipe for Thanksgiving Dessert Recipe Ideas.

If you love pumpkin pie but are looking for a twist on traditional recipes, you must try Michele’s buttermilk pumpkin pie idea.

It’s simple to make with a prepared pie crust and minimum ingredients.

READ Recipe

Easy Pecan Pie

By Jen at Midwest Life and Style

Pecan Pie Thanksgiving Dessert Recipes.

Thanksgiving wouldn’t be the same without a pecan pie. Jen shared this oohy-gooey easy Thanksgiving Dessert Recipe that anyone can make.

Doesn’t it look wonderful?

READ Recipe

Decadent Keto Chocolate Hazelnut Pie

By Simply 2 Moms

Healthy Keto Chocolate  Hazelnut Pie For Thanksgiving Pie Recipes that are sure to please.

Looking for a healthy Keto Thanksgiving Pie Recipe? It’s always good to have healthy dessert options, and Simply 2 Moms are experts in healthy recipes.

Their Decadent Keto Chocolate Hazelnut Pie Recipe will be a crowd favorite for sure. READ Recipe

Eggnog Custard and Gingerbread Pie Recipe

By Diane at South House Design

Eggnog custard and gingerbread pie recipes.

What better way to start the holiday season than by combining two of our favorite traditions? Eggnog and gingerbread are traditional holiday staples that will surely be on your recipe list for years to come.

Diane’s delicious Eggnog Custard Pie Recipe is full of gingerbread goodness, and I can’t wait to try it.

READ Recipe

A Few Additional Holiday Favorites

In addition to these yummy Thanksgiving Pie Recipes, I decided to include a few of our family’s holiday favorites.

Holiday Recipes

Family Favorites

Thanks so much for stopping by today, and I hope these recipes add to your Thanksgiving enjoyment.

Pin It To Remember It

Did you find some great ideas you’d like to save for future reference? Hover over the images you’d like to save and pin to your favorite Pinterest Boards when you see the PIN button.

Thanksgiving Pie Recipes perfect for holiday gatherings. Easy Thanksgiving Dessert Recipes that will wow your guests.


Thursday 2nd of November 2023

These all look so amazing Rachel. I'm going to share this with my readers on Saturday!


Friday 3rd of November 2023

Ann, I really appreciate that.

Stacy Ling

Tuesday 31st of October 2023

So many amazing recipes!


Tuesday 31st of October 2023

Yes, I agree.


Saturday 28th of October 2023

All of these pies look so delicious. And I can't wait to try your cranberry pie. Yum!


Sunday 29th of October 2023

Jen, Thanks so much.

Kim | Shiplap and Shells

Saturday 28th of October 2023

I can't decide! I will have to try them All!


Sunday 29th of October 2023

Kim, I agree they all sound yummy.


Saturday 28th of October 2023

Yum! These sound delicious!


Sunday 29th of October 2023

Renae, They really are. Thanks for stopping by.